• Posts
    • Bowhunting Articles
    • Bowhunting News
    • Bowhunting Gear
  • Interviews
    • Straight Shot Blog
  • Videos
  • Deer Pictures By Robert Hoague
  • Cooking Wild Game
    • Cooking With SusieQ
  • Wild Hogs
  • Bowfishing
  • Events
  • Contact
Sunday, January 29, 2023
Bowhunting.Net
  • Login
  • Register
  • Bowhunting Articles
  • Interviews
    • Straight Shot Blog
  • Bowhunting Videos
  • Deer
  • Wild Turkey
  • Scouting
  • Bear
  • Cooking Wild Game
    • Cooking With SusieQ
    • Wild Game Cooking
No Result
View All Result
  • Bowhunting Articles
  • Interviews
    • Straight Shot Blog
  • Bowhunting Videos
  • Deer
  • Wild Turkey
  • Scouting
  • Bear
  • Cooking Wild Game
    • Cooking With SusieQ
    • Wild Game Cooking
No Result
View All Result
Bowhunting.Net
No Result
View All Result
Home Bowhunting Posts

Bowhunting or Birth Control?

Dr. Dave Samuel by Dr. Dave Samuel
April 26, 2014 - Updated on February 24, 2020
in Bowhunting Posts
0 0
A A
1
whitetail buck

BANNERSponsored by: HECS STEALTHSCREEN & ATSKO

By: Dr. Dave Samuel
By: Dr. Dave Samuel

When towns and cities have a deer problem, as thousands do, and the citizens want something done, the leaders of those towns and cities put together a citizen’s committee to assess the situation. Invariably, they consider all options from capture and removal to bowhunting. Invariably all the options prove to be either illegal under state or federal laws, or they don’t work. All except one . . . bowhunting. Even though bowhunting is working in thousands of communities to safely help citizens with their deer problems, those against killing deer always (and I mean always) suggest the use of chemosterilants or sterilization. The purpose of this column is to provide individuals some information relative to that option so you can stand up and oppose it.

Why oppose it? For one reason, it doesn’t work. Another good reason is because it is extremely expensive. Another problem is that there is only one drug that is legal under federal law and so far, for deer, it can’t control deer numbers in a town or city.

Deer in back yards is become a common sight in thousands of cities and towns.
Deer in back yards is become a common sight in thousands of cities and towns.

So, the question becomes, should you use bowhunting or birth control when you town has a deer problem? Let’s review the situation.

Cayuga Heights in New York, which borders Cornell University, has a deer problem. Several years ago, when they tried to solve it, things got nasty. There was lots of controversy and litigation in Cayuga Heights. After the dust settled, that town decided to implement a two-year sterilization program. In 2012 they spent $148,315 removing ovaries from 137 does. Even after spending more than $1,000 per animal, a Cornell University deer count that cost the town more than $20,000, showed they still had 125 per square mile. Hard to imagine a town holding that number of deer. When you have 125 per square mile, you have an ecological and disease potential disaster for citizens living there.

11urbanbuck2

In December 2013, they sterilized 12 does at a cost of $35,808. That’s a mere $2,984 per doe. The mayor explained that away by saying that costs can be expected to go up as deer numbers drop, but with 125 deer per square mile, it would seem there are lots of deer out there. Truth be told, the deer sterilization program just isn’t working. On top of that for the year 2013, one report added that the city’s legal fees related to the deer hunt were more than $8,200. And don’t forget that cost for counting the deer. Apparently Cayuga Heights is a wealthy community.

All this makes me wonder why the City Council in Fairfax City, Virginia recently voted to approve a deer sterilization program. However, even though the proposed cost is expected to run around $1,000 per doe, they are going ahead for two reasons. They feel that using volunteer veterinarians will lower costs to $500 per doe. In addition, a group of private donors agreed to fund a two-year grant to cover the costs of the project.

11deer-in-yard

All that is fine and dandy, but just because someone else is paying for this program, doesn’t change the fact that deer sterilization or the use of chemosterilants doesn’t work in towns or cities, or any large, unfenced area. That is why all state wildlife agencies, including the New York Department of Environmental Conservation and the Virginia DNR do not approve of these options. They do not work. In fact, studies show that they will only work in small fenced areas and other areas smaller than 100 acres.

What are the problems with sterilization or chemosterilants? Cost is an obvious problem. Also, deer move a lot, negating any sterilization done. Studies show that you just can’t sterilize enough does. Research shows that you need to sterilize 80 percent of all does in a town, just to keep the population stable. That’s impossible to do, physically or financially.

Often towns have way too many deer, and when that happens, local  vegetation in yards and  parks will develop browse lines that signify ecological damage to habitat, native flowers,  etc.
Often towns have way too many deer, and when that happens, local vegetation in yards and parks will develop browse lines that signify ecological damage to habitat, native flowers, etc.

So, what are the advantages of a bowhunting program. First, there is almost no cost to taxpayers. Second, you can take out problem deer that have decided to eat your yard and everything in it. Third, it is safe. No matter how loud opponents scream, there has never been an accident involving an arrow in any urban bowhunt in the country. No question, with thousands of such hunts now taking place, some day there will be an accident, but none so far. Fourth, a bowhunt makes deer less likely to hang around. Hunted deer are less likely to eat your garden, shrubs, etc. Hunted deer are less likely to stay in your area.

And that is the purpose of an urban bowhunt. The purpose isn’t to kill all the deer. The purpose is to lower numbers, to make your area safer, reduce auto/deer collisions, to reduce the potential for human disease via deer ticks, and to reduce yard and ecological damage.

A bowhunt reduces the problems deer cause. And most of the citizens living where there is an urban bowhunt don’t even know the bowhunters are out there. Meat is often given to local soup kitchens, and once implemented, most citizens support the bowhunt. The bowhunters are good citizens helping out their town. The next time someone opposes an urban bowhunt and suggests sterilizing does, show them the facts. Apparently only a very few, wealthy, towns can afford to ignore the facts.

For more please go to: The Future of Hunting

And for more please go to: HECS   and Atsko

Previous Post

Gear Review: The White’s Tale Board Game

Next Post

New XCEL Action Cameras: Capture Your Adventures with Spypoint

Next Post

New XCEL Action Cameras: Capture Your Adventures with Spypoint

A Lion’s Tale

Hog Nut: Does It Make Wild Hogs Nuts?

HSS & ScoutLook Spread Treestand Safety Message

Comments 1

  1. Chase M Rogers says:
    9 years ago

    Not to mention that it would stimulate the economy through the retail department, help programs that feed the homeless and less fortunate with tons of meat and getting youths more involved in the outdoors!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Wild Turkey Cajun Pasta
  • Archers Top 3 Shooting Mistakes
  • New For Grim Reaper Broadheads For 2023
  • Vosker Cell Camera- Two Year Field Test
  • More ‘Big 10’ – Part 3
  • Make A Scrape Tree The Steve Bartylla Way!
  • Bowhunting Articles
  • Interviews
  • Bowhunting Videos
  • Deer
  • Wild Turkey
  • Scouting
  • Bear
  • Cooking Wild Game

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Bowhunting Articles
  • Bowhunting Videos
  • Deer
  • Bowhunting Gear
  • Western Bowhunting
    • Elk
  • Wild Turkey
  • Cooking Wild Game
  • Wild Turkey Bowhunters Blog
  • Straight Shot Blog
  • Register
  • Activate
  • The Original Bowhunting Website & Blog. Online Since 1996.
  • Robert Hoague Field Notes, Photos & Blog

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
-
00:00
00:00

Queue

Update Required Flash plugin
-
00:00
00:00